PIA VPN vs ExpressVPN: A Detailed 2023 Comparison

PIA (Private Internet Access) VPN and ExpressVPN are renowned names in the VPN landscape, each boasting a unique set of features and capabilities.

PIA VPN is a US-based VPN service known for its robust security protocols, affordable pricing plans, and support for simultaneous connections. It’s widely used for activities like secure browsing, streaming, and torrenting.

On the other hand, ExpressVPN is a British Virgin Islands-based VPN provider, renowned for its speed, security, and broad server network. It’s highly favored for bypassing geo-blocks on streaming platforms like Netflix, Hulu, and BBC iPlayer.

In this article, we’ll dissect the features of PIA VPN and ExpressVPN, scrutinizing their security and encryption protocols, no-log policies, server networks, streaming capabilities, torrenting support, compatibility, pricing plans, and customer support. This comparison aims to provide an unbiased review to help potential users choose the right VPN.

Security and Encryption

In the realm of VPNs, security and encryption are non-negotiable. VPNs use encryption to scramble your data into an unreadable format, protecting it from potential eavesdroppers. They also provide security protocols to safely transmit your data over the internet.

Why is this important? Without robust security measures, cybercriminals could intercept and misuse your sensitive information, resulting in potential data breaches or identity theft.

Comparison of the Security Features and Encryption Methods of PIA VPN and ExpressVPN

PIA VPN employs AES-256 encryption, the same standard used by governments and cybersecurity experts worldwide. For VPN protocols, it supports OpenVPN and WireGuard®, which are known for their security and speed, respectively. Additionally, it offers a kill switch feature, which blocks all internet traffic if the VPN connection drops, thus preventing accidental data leaks.

ExpressVPN, similarly, uses AES-256 encryption. It provides a selection of VPN protocols, including Lightway (its proprietary protocol), OpenVPN, IKEv2, and L2TP/IPSec. Like PIA, it also offers a Network Lock (similar to a kill switch), ensuring no data leak if the VPN connection unexpectedly drops.

As of my knowledge cutoff in September 2021, both VPNs provide strong encryption and secure protocols, thus ensuring that your data remains confidential and secure.

Here’s a quick comparison table:

	PIA VPN	ExpressVPN
Encryption	AES-256	AES-256
Protocols	OpenVPN, WireGuard®	Lightway, OpenVPN, IKEv2, L2TP/IPSec
Kill switch	Yes	Yes

Pros and Cons for Each VPN in Terms of Security and Encryption

While both VPNs offer strong encryption and security protocols, there are a few differences to note. The choice between the two may come down to individual preference and specific use cases.

PIA VPN

Pros:

• Offers both OpenVPN and WireGuard®, allowing users to choose between top-tier security or speed.
• It provides an ad and malware blocker (MACE) for additional security.

Cons:

• Being based in the US (a Five Eyes Alliance member), it may be subject to stringent data retention laws, although it maintains a strict no-logs policy.

ExpressVPN

Pros:

• Provides a variety of protocols, including its proprietary Lightway protocol, which is designed for speed and reliability.
• Its location in the British Virgin Islands is ideal for privacy, as it’s outside the 14 Eyes Alliance jurisdiction.

Cons:

• It lacks an inbuilt ad and malware blocker, which PIA provides.

Conclusion on Which VPN Provides Better Security and Encryption

In terms of security and encryption, both PIA VPN and ExpressVPN stand on a solid ground. However, the choice depends on individual needs and concerns. For instance, if an inbuilt ad-blocker is crucial to you, PIA VPN would be a better choice. Conversely, if jurisdiction matters to you, ExpressVPN’s location outside the 14 Eyes Alliance is a definite advantage.

No-log Policy & Jurisdiction

When it comes to privacy, the VPN’s no-log policy and jurisdiction play a pivotal role. A no-log policy ensures that your online activities are not recorded or stored by the VPN provider. This means even if the provider is compelled to hand over data by the authorities, they simply won’t have anything to give.

The jurisdiction refers to the country where the VPN provider is registered. This matters because each country has different laws and regulations concerning data retention and surveillance. For instance, VPN providers based in countries that are part of the ’14 Eyes Alliance’ can be legally compelled to share user data.

Did you know? The ’14 Eyes Alliance’ is a group of countries that share intelligence data with each other, potentially including user data from internet service providers and VPNs.

Comparison of PIA VPN and ExpressVPN’s No-log Policies and Their Jurisdictions

PIA VPN operates under the jurisdiction of the United States, a member of the ‘Five Eyes Alliance’. Despite this, PIA VPN maintains a strict no-logs policy. They affirm that they do not log any traffic or usage by their customers. PIA VPN’s commitment to privacy was verified in 2020 when its no-log policy was proven in court for the second time.

ExpressVPN, based in the British Virgin Islands (BVI), operates in a privacy-friendly jurisdiction. BVI has no data retention laws and is not a member of any surveillance alliance like ’14 Eyes’. ExpressVPN also follows a strict no-log policy. They do not store any logs of user activity, DNS queries, or connection logs. Their policy was independently audited by PwC (PricewaterhouseCoopers), offering further transparency and reliability.

Let’s look at a quick comparison table:

	PIA VPN	ExpressVPN
Jurisdiction	United States (Five Eyes Alliance member)	British Virgin Islands (No surveillance alliances)
No-log Policy	Yes (Verified in court)	Yes (Independently audited by PwC)

Pros and Cons for Each VPN Based on Their No-log Policy and Jurisdiction

PIA VPN

Pros:

• Strict no-log policy that has been tested and proven in court.

Cons:

• Located in the United States, a member of the ‘Five Eyes Alliance’, which could raise potential privacy concerns for some users.

ExpressVPN

Pros:

• Strict no-log policy that has been independently audited and verified.
• Based in the British Virgin Islands, a privacy-friendly jurisdiction outside any surveillance alliance.

Cons:

• There are no major downsides in terms of no-log policy and jurisdiction.

Conclusion on Which VPN Has a Better No-log Policy and Jurisdiction

ExpressVPN takes the edge in this category due to its jurisdiction in the privacy-friendly British Virgin Islands and independently audited no-log policy. While PIA VPN has a proven no-log policy, its jurisdiction within the ‘Five Eyes Alliance’ may be a concern for some privacy-focused users.

Server Network

A VPN’s server network is vital for a couple of reasons. First, a broader server network means more options for you to connect, making it easier to bypass geo-restrictions. Second, the server location affects the speed of your connection – the closer the server, the faster your connection.

Comparison of the Server Networks of PIA VPN and ExpressVPN

PIA VPN boasts an impressive server count, with over 29,650 servers spread across 70+ countries as of my last knowledge update in September 2021. This wide network coverage ensures you can find a server that suits your needs, whether for speed or geo-unblocking.

ExpressVPN, while not offering as many servers as PIA, excels in its geographic diversity. With 3000+ servers across 94 countries, it provides a truly global reach. The benefit of this wide distribution is that you’re likely to find a server nearby, no matter where you are.

Here’s a comparison table:

	PIA VPN	ExpressVPN
Server Count	29,650+	3,000+
Countries Covered	70+	94

Pros and Cons for Each VPN Based on Server Network

PIA VPN

Pros:

• Large number of servers to choose from.
• Good geographical coverage.

Cons:

• Lesser country coverage compared to ExpressVPN.

ExpressVPN

Pros:

• Wide geographical spread covering 94 countries.
• High-quality server performance.

Cons:

• Fewer servers than PIA VPN.

Conclusion on Which VPN Has a Better Server Network

While PIA VPN offers a larger number of servers, ExpressVPN has a broader country coverage. Both aspects are beneficial depending on individual user requirements. If you’re looking for a wide variety of server choices, PIA VPN may be the better option. However, if you require access to servers in a larger number of countries, ExpressVPN would be more suitable.

Streaming

In the world of streaming, VPNs are a game-changer. They help bypass geographical restrictions imposed by streaming platforms, giving you access to a world of content that may otherwise be unavailable in your region. But not all VPNs are created equal; some are more capable at this task than others, and the speed and stability they offer can also vary widely.

Comparison of the Streaming Capabilities of PIA VPN and ExpressVPN

Let’s look at how PIA VPN and ExpressVPN fare in terms of streaming capabilities:

PIA VPN is equipped to unblock numerous streaming platforms, but its performance can be inconsistent. While it can usually unblock US Netflix, it can struggle with other regional libraries and platforms like BBC iPlayer.

On the other hand, ExpressVPN is renowned for its excellent streaming capabilities. It consistently unblocks many popular platforms, including Netflix, Hulu, BBC iPlayer, Amazon Prime Video, and Disney+, regardless of the user’s location. Moreover, its fast speeds ensure a smooth, buffering-free streaming experience.

	PIA VPN	ExpressVPN
Unblocks Netflix	US mostly	Yes (multiple libraries)
Unblocks Hulu	Sometimes	Yes
Unblocks BBC iPlayer	Rarely	Yes
Unblocks Amazon Prime Video	Sometimes	Yes
Unblocks Disney+	Sometimes	Yes

Pros and Cons for Each VPN in Terms of Streaming Capabilities

PIA VPN

Pros:

• Able to unblock US Netflix.

Cons:

• Inconsistent at unblocking other streaming platforms and non-US Netflix libraries.

ExpressVPN

Pros:

• Consistently unblocks numerous streaming platforms.
• Provides fast, reliable connections for seamless streaming.

Cons:

• More expensive than other VPNs with similar streaming capabilities.

Conclusion on Which VPN Offers Better Streaming Capabilities

ExpressVPN is the clear winner in this category. Its ability to consistently unblock a range of streaming platforms, coupled with its high-speed servers, make it an excellent choice for streamers.

Torrenting

Torrenting, while a popular method of file sharing, can expose your IP address to anyone who’s interested, including cybercriminals and surveillance agencies. A good VPN helps shield this exposure by providing an anonymous IP address, making sure your torrenting activities remain private.

Comparison of the Torrenting Capabilities of PIA VPN and ExpressVPN

When it comes to torrenting, both PIA VPN and ExpressVPN offer robust features.

PIA VPN supports P2P file sharing on all its servers. It also includes an automatic kill switch to protect your data if the VPN connection drops unexpectedly. Furthermore, its MACE feature provides ad, tracker, and malware blocking, enhancing your torrenting experience.

ExpressVPN also supports torrenting on all its servers. It includes a Network Lock feature — similar to a kill switch — and offers impressive download speeds. While it doesn’t offer a built-in ad blocker like PIA, it makes up for it with higher speed and overall reliability.

Here’s a comparison:

	PIA VPN	ExpressVPN
P2P Support on All Servers	Yes	Yes
Kill Switch	Yes	Yes (Network Lock)
Ad and Malware Blocker	Yes (MACE feature)	No
Speed	Fast	Very Fast

Pros and Cons for Each VPN in Terms of Torrenting Capabilities

PIA VPN

Pros:

• Supports P2P on all servers.
• Includes MACE for ad, tracker, and malware blocking.

Cons:

• Slower speeds compared to ExpressVPN.

ExpressVPN

Pros:

• Supports P2P on all servers.
• Offers very fast speeds for quick downloads.

Cons:

• No built-in ad or malware blocker.

Conclusion on Which VPN is Better for Torrenting

Both VPNs support torrenting and provide security features like a kill switch. However, ExpressVPN takes the lead due to its superior speed, crucial for large downloads. While PIA VPN’s MACE feature is a bonus, it doesn’t offset the speed advantage of ExpressVPN for torrenting.

Compatibility and Ease of Use

A good VPN isn’t just secure and fast—it’s also versatile and user-friendly. Compatibility with a wide range of devices and operating systems ensures you can enjoy the benefits of a VPN whether you’re using a computer, smartphone, or smart TV. A user-friendly interface, meanwhile, makes the process of installing and using the VPN much easier, especially for beginners.

Comparison of the Compatibility and Ease of Use of PIA VPN and ExpressVPN

Let’s look at how PIA VPN and ExpressVPN stack up in terms of compatibility and ease of use.

PIA VPN offers dedicated apps for all major platforms, including Windows, macOS, Android, and iOS. In addition, it provides setup guides for other devices and platforms, such as Linux, routers, and more. The user interface is clean and easy to navigate, but some users might find the range of options and settings overwhelming at first.

ExpressVPN offers a similar level of compatibility, with dedicated apps for Windows, macOS, Android, iOS, Linux, and even some smart TVs and gaming consoles. Its apps are known for their simplicity and user-friendliness. Plus, the ExpressVPN website hosts detailed setup guides for a myriad of other devices.

Here’s a side-by-side comparison:

	PIA VPN	ExpressVPN
Windows	Yes	Yes
macOS	Yes	Yes
Android	Yes	Yes
iOS	Yes	Yes
Linux	Guides	Yes
Routers	Guides	Yes
Smart TVs	No	Yes
Gaming Consoles	No	Yes
User Interface	Comprehensive, slightly complex	Simple, intuitive

Pros and Cons for Each VPN Based on Compatibility and Ease of Use

PIA VPN

Pros:

• Compatible with most major platforms.
• Offers a wide range of settings for advanced users.

Cons:

• The interface can be overwhelming for beginners.
• No native support for smart TVs or gaming consoles.

ExpressVPN

Pros:

• Broad compatibility, including smart TVs and gaming consoles.
• User-friendly interface suitable for beginners and advanced users alike.

Cons:

• None

Conclusion on Which VPN is More Compatible and Easier to Use

ExpressVPN is the clear winner in this category. While both VPNs are compatible with most devices and operating systems, ExpressVPN’s extended support for smart TVs and gaming consoles gives it an edge. Furthermore, its simple and intuitive interface makes it a great option for both VPN beginners and tech-savvy users.

Pricing

A good VPN is an investment in your online privacy and security, but that doesn’t mean it needs to break the bank. It’s important to find a VPN that offers a good balance of features and affordability. Let’s see how PIA VPN and ExpressVPN stack up.

Comparison of the Pricing Plans of PIA VPN and ExpressVPN

PIA VPN is one of the more affordable VPNs on the market. As of my knowledge cutoff in September 2021, it offers a monthly plan, a yearly plan, and a two-year plan, with the latter offering the best value for money.

ExpressVPN, on the other hand, is more expensive, reflecting its premium features and reputation. It also offers three plans: a monthly plan, a six-month plan, and a yearly plan, which includes three extra months free.

Here’s a quick comparison:

	PIA VPN	ExpressVPN
Monthly Plan	Yes	Yes
6-Month Plan	No	Yes
Yearly Plan	Yes	Yes
Two-Year Plan	Yes	No
Extra Months Free	No	Yes (with the yearly plan)

Pros and Cons for Each VPN Based on Pricing

PIA VPN

Pros:

• More affordable than many competitors.
• Offers a two-year plan for even better value.

Cons:

• No extra months free.

ExpressVPN

Pros:

• Provides premium features and excellent performance.
• Offers three extra months free with the yearly plan.

Cons:

• More expensive than many competitors.
• No two-year plan.

Conclusion on Which VPN Offers Better Value for Money

While PIA VPN is the more affordable option, ExpressVPN offers a better balance of cost and performance. With its extensive range of features and top-notch service, ExpressVPN provides excellent value for money, despite being pricier. But if you’re on a tight budget and willing to compromise on some features, PIA VPN is a viable option.

Customer Support

Even the most advanced VPN services can sometimes experience issues, and when they do, you want to know that there’s a knowledgeable and helpful support team ready to assist you. A responsive, 24/7 customer support service is an important feature to look for in a VPN.

Comparison of the Customer Support offered by PIA VPN and ExpressVPN

Customer service is an area where these two VPNs significantly differ.

PIA VPN provides customer support primarily through its ticketing system and a comprehensive knowledge base on its website. They do not offer live chat, which means you may have to wait for a response to your queries.

On the other hand, ExpressVPN has a 24/7 live chat service and an email support system. Their website also hosts an extensive selection of guides, FAQs, and troubleshooting resources.

Here’s a side-by-side comparison:

	PIA VPN	ExpressVPN
24/7 Live Chat	No	Yes
Email Support	Yes	Yes
Knowledge Base	Yes	Yes
Response Time	Hours to days	Minutes

Pros and Cons for Each VPN in terms of Customer Support

PIA VPN

Pros:

• Comprehensive knowledge base.
• Email support.

Cons:

• No live chat support.
• Response times can be long.

ExpressVPN

Pros:

• 24/7 live chat support.
• Fast response times.
• Comprehensive knowledge base.

Cons:

• None

Conclusion on Which VPN Provides Better Customer Support

When it comes to customer support, ExpressVPN is the clear winner. The availability of 24/7 live chat support and fast response times make it a more reliable choice for users who might need immediate assistance. While PIA VPN has a solid knowledge base, the absence of live chat and slower response times put it at a disadvantage.

Conclusion

In our comprehensive comparison, we’ve covered key aspects including security and encryption, no-log policy and jurisdiction, server network, streaming and torrenting capabilities, compatibility and ease of use, pricing, and customer support.

Overall Comparison Table (PIA VPN vs ExpressVPN)

Here’s a summary of how PIA VPN and ExpressVPN stack up:

Feature	PIA VPN	ExpressVPN	Winner
Security and Encryption	Strong	Strong	ExpressVPN
No-log Policy & Jurisdiction	Yes, USA	Yes, British Virgin Islands	ExpressVPN
Server Network	Large network	Large network, better global spread	ExpressVPN
Streaming	Good, supports popular platforms	Excellent, supports more platforms	ExpressVPN
Torrenting	Allowed	Allowed, with more reliable speeds	ExpressVPN
Compatibility and Ease of Use	Comprehensive, slightly complex	User-friendly, more device compatibility	ExpressVPN
Pricing	Affordable	Higher, but offers more value	PIA VPN
Customer Support	Email support, no live chat	24/7 live chat, fast response	ExpressVPN

In this comparison, ExpressVPN is the winner in most categories, except for pricing where PIA VPN is more affordable.

Final Thoughts on the Better VPN Based on the Analyzed Factors

Overall, both PIA VPN and ExpressVPN have their strengths and offer quality services. However, considering all the factors, ExpressVPN edges out PIA VPN due to its wider range of device compatibility, better global server coverage, superior customer support, and consistent performance in all areas. It offers a user-friendly interface, top-notch security, and it excels in streaming and torrenting. Although it comes at a higher price point, the value delivered justifies the cost.

Choosing a VPN ultimately comes down to individual needs and preferences. If budget is your main concern and you don’t mind a bit of a learning curve, PIA VPN is a good choice. However, if you’re looking for a VPN that delivers exceptional performance across the board and provides a straightforward, user-friendly experience, ExpressVPN would be the way to go.

FAQ